I also promised that eventually I would post the answers here. So if you haven't read any of them yet and still want to be surprised, you may want to stop reading here...
And the list goes like this:
1. The Eye at the Door: True
2. Hell Shower: True!
3. The Burns Street Disturbance: True
4. The Lady in Red: True!
5. The Hounds of Blairsden: (Though it was based on a very real place, the story itself is) False
6. The Bullet Hole: True
7. Boo!: True!
8. Mrs. Lee: True
9. Another Burns Street Disturbance: True (my dad's house is totally haunted!)
10. The Drowned Dog: False (though unfortunately I did once come across a drowned dog on a beach... so sad!)
11. The Yowl: Totally true!
12. The Devil's Tree: True
13. The Driveway: The murder story is true... The ghost story is fake... so the answer is ... duh... False.
14. Yet Another Burns Street Disturbance: True
15. The Ouija Board: True
16. After the Spirit Board: True
17. The Kelsens: .... .... .... and the final answer is... False! (obviously. though wouldn't it be cool if it were true? I think so.)
Anyway, thanks to everyone who played. If you haven't read the stories, it's not too late. Share 'em with your friends, classes, family. This could be a fun party game... IMHO.
Cheers, during a very unscary December,